IS YOUR HOME A HEALTH HAZARD?
By Lyse M. Tremblay

It is now acknowledged by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) that houses contain substances that may be hazardous to our health. In fact, the air inside the home may be more seriously polluted than the outdoor air in the largest and most industrialized cities. In view of the fact that approximately 90% of our time is spent indoors, the risks to our health from indoor air pollution for many of us may be greater than the risks from outdoor air pollution.

Most houses contain a number of pollutant sources and while exposure to one pollutant source may not in itself be a problem, exposure to a number of them can present a serious risk. The pollutants can enter our bodies in one of three ways:
1) through our food or water
2) through materials and furnishings we touch and
3) through the air that we breathe. Although houses are mostly responsible for pollutants absorbed as a result of the air that we breathe, these will be in addition to the rest of the pollutant load that our bodies have absorbed, thereby increasing our total load.

Naturally, not everyone will be affected in the same way by an exposure to pollutants. Factors such as heredity, diet, lifestyle, age, and pre-existing medical conditions all affect our particular susceptibility.

WHO IS MOST AT RISK

CMHC separates people into three categories ranging from those most at risk to those least at risk. Most at risk are individuals who are hypersensitive to a number of agents and who react adversely to extremely low levels of exposure. This condition is commonly described as "environmental allergy", "environmental hypersensitivity" or "environmental illness". According to a report on housing for the environmentally hypersensitive prepared for the Research Division of CMHC, the symptoms reported by those affected ranged from central nervous system problems such as tension, fatigue, headaches, depression and inability to concentrate to problems with other physical systems such as gastrointestinal, respiratory, musculoskeletal, genitourinary, EENT (eyes, ears, nose and throat), skin and cardiovascular. The symptoms were often severe enough to interfere with a person's ability to function normally. Biochemical individuality (heredity or mother's health and nutritional state during pregnancy), total body burden (biological stress including illness, psychological state and all forms of irritants and toxic contaminants) and nutritional state were stated as factors that may predispose one to hypersensitivity.

The onset was reported as being triggered by the following:

The report also notes that the chemical sensitivities of the hypersensitives were mostly always associated with parallel sensitivities to biological contaminants such as molds and dust as well as to food allergies. Hypersensitive individuals tested positive in conventional allergies as well as clinical ecology tests. It was also reported, however, that a reduced exposure or total avoidance of the environmental irritants or incitants reduced the food allergy sensitivities to some extent and that all the participants reported an improvement in their health following a change of habitat that excluded chemical exposure to even minute levels of contaminants but included clean air, clean water, and clean food

It is interesting to note the similarities between this group and most sufferers of endometriosis. In addition, the profile of the respondents who had made modifications to their homes in order to improve their health indicated that 83% were female, 93% were over the age of 30, 76% became ill in adult life, 93% had been sick for over 6 years and 27% were currently disabled. In light of the research on dioxins and endometriosis, the similarities may be more than just coincidental.

The second group at risk are the people with known health issues such as respiratory or cardiovascular diseases, allergies, chemical sensitivities, chronic illnesses or those who spend a lot of time in the home such as women, children, the elderly or the infirm. For this group, the home needs to be altered so as to lessen the effects of any known irritant and avert risk.

The third group consists of people who have no known reaction to low levels of contaminants and are in relatively good health. The issue for them would be to improve comfort and prevent potential health problems from occurring. Prevention for this last group is indeed very important because just as some health effects may be experienced soon after a single pollutant exposure, other effects may not occur until years later. Some people can become sensitized to biological and chemical pollutants as a result of a high exposure level or a long and repeated exposure level.

It is therefore important to deal with the issue of indoor air pollution even if physical symptoms are not noticeable and particularly important to take corrective action if you have a known health issue or are hypersensitive.

POLLUTANTS, HEALTH EFFECTS, SOURCES AND SOLUTIONS(compiled from EPA and CMHC sources)

BIOLOGICAL CONTAMINANTS

Substance: Molds, mildew, dust mites, pollen, animal dander and cat saliva, bacteria and viruses.Health effects: Eye, nose, throat irritation; shortness of breath dizziness, lethargy, fever, digestive problems, asthma, humidifier fever, influenza, infectious diseases, sensitization to substances, allergic reactions, hypersensitivity pneumonitis, allergic rhinitis.
Sources: High (above 60-70%) humidity levels, leaky house components or pipes causing water accumulation, humidifier, air conditioner or refrigerator trays or drainage pans, condensation on interior surfaces, rotting house structures (e.g., windows, floors and framing); damp or moist house furnishings (e.g., carpets, furniture, wall coverings, mattresses, paper, clothing); potted plants (soil can support fungal growth); cold, uninsulated or unventilated places (e.g., cold cellars, crawl spaces, basements); drains; dirty filters; indoor storage of firewood; damp and dirty surfaces; house dust (e.g., furnishings, mattresses, carpets, ducts, exposed surfaces); pollen (e.g.,indoor plants, nearby outdoor plants), pets.
Solutions: Reduce humidity level in house with dehumidifier or air conditioners; ventilate to prevent moisture buildup in kitchens, bathrooms, basements and attics; minimize the use of humidifiers and clean them regularly, keep drain pans clean; repair household leaks and remove rotting, damp or water damaged materials; clean regularly and vacuum, preferably with a central vacuum system vented outdoors; avoid dust accumulating furnishings (e.g., upholstered furniture, drapes, carpets); use allergen proof mattress encasements; use electrostatic or high efficiency filters in air handling units, and clean or replace them frequently; cover soil on potted plants and do not overwater them; confine pets to one area of the house or eliminate them entirely.

CHEMICAL CONTAMINANTS

Substance: Combustion gases and respirable particles (carbon monoxide and nitrogen dioxide)
Health effects: Carbon monoxide-in low concentrations: fatigue in healthy people and chest pains in people with heart disease; at higher concentrations: impaired vision and coordination, headaches, dizziness, confusion, nausea, flue like symptoms;at very high concentrations: fatal. Nitrogen dioxide-eye, nose and throat irritation, potential impaired lung function and increased respiratory infections in young children, Respirable particles same as nitrogen dioxide with the addition of bronchitis and lung cancer.
Sources: Unvented kerosene or gas stoves and heaters, woodstoves, fireplaces, leaking or backdrafting chimneys and furnaces, automobile exhaust, tobacco smoke.Solutions:Vent furnaces,gas stoves and space heaters to outdoors; replace gas devices with electric devices; select properly sized woodstoves with tightly fitting doors that are certified to meet EPA emission standards; have trained professionals inspect,clean and tune up central heating system annually, do not idle car in the garage, do not smoke in the home or if smoking cannot be avoided increase ventilation where smoking takes place and use exhaust fans.

Substance: Pesticides, insecticides, termicides, fungicides, rodentcides and disinfectantsHealth effects: Irritation to eyes, nose and throat; damage to central nervous system and kidneys; increased risk of cancer.
Sources: Pesticide use, pesticide residue in homes from previous pesticide use, products on lawns and gardens that drift or are tracked inside, mothballs, stored pesticide containers, household surfaces that collect and then release pesticides.
Solutions: Use alternative pest control methods; do not store pesticide containers inside the home; store clothes with moth repellent in separate ventilated areas; use pesticides only when absolutely necessary and with care.

Substance: Organic gases (Volatile organic compounds, or VOCs) and formaldehydeHealth effects: Eye, nose and throat irritation; headaches; loss of coordination; nausea; damage to liver, kidney, central nervous system; cancer or suspected cancer; skin rashes; severe allergic reactions; fatigue; wheezing and coughing.Sources:Paint, paint strippers, varnishes, furniture oils, caulkings, glues, adhesives, wood preservatives, aerosol sprays, cleaners and disinfectants, moth repellents, air fresheners, stored fuel and automotive products, dry cleaned clothing, hobby supplies, drywall compound, soft plastics, pressed wood products, urea formaldehyde foam insulation, permanent press fabrics on clothes, furnishings, furniture and draperies, carpets and underpads, wallcoverings or floor coverings made of vinyl, plastic or other synthetics, upholstered furniture containing synthetic foam, personal care products (perfumes, cosmetics and toiletries).
Solutions: Substitute with unscented, nontoxic products; avoid cleaning agents containing chlorine and other organic solvents; store supplies outside or in closet equipped with exhaust fan; use low toxicity, low odor paints, varnishes, oils, caulkings and other building materials; air out dry cleaned clothes; do not use room deodorizers, mothballs or fabric softeners; replace pressed wood products with low toxicity products or seal pressed wood products with appropriate sealers; increase ventilation to 1 air change every 3 hours so as to evacuate chemicals that do outgass and maintain moderate temperature and humidity so as to discourage the release of formaldehyde; use low toxicity, natural non-dyed, non-fireproofed, non-mothproofed, non-allergenic furnishings and materials. (All-Natural does not necessarily mean non-allergenic). Controversy exists over the use of plants as significant absorbers of formaldehyde and other gases (natural air cleaners), do not rely on them exclusively.

Substance: Lead
Health effects: Affects practically all body systems; can cause convulsions, coma and death at high levels; at low levels, it can have health effects on the central nervous system, kidneys and blood cells. It can also impair mental and physical development.
Sources: Lead based paint, contaminated soil or dust, lead based water pipes, lead based dinnerware
Solutions: Do not disturb lead based paint in good condition; do not sand or burn lead painted surfaces; seek expert help in removing lead paint; do not bring lead dust into the home; have house water pipes tested for lead contamination; test dinnerware for lead contamination.

Substance: Asbestos
Health effects: Long term risk of chest or abdominal cancers and lung diseases. Smokers have increased risk.
Sources: Deteriorating, damaged or disturbed insulation, fireproofing, acoustical materials and floor tiles from older homes.
Solutions: leave undamaged asbestos material alone. If material damaged, consult expert asbestos removal contractors.

Substance: Radon
Health effects: Lung cancer. Smokers at higher risk.
Sources: Earth and rock beneath the home may produce gas that seeps in through openings in the foundations, well water in radon area, radon laden building materialsSolutions: Have home tested for radon exposure.

TAKING APPROPRIATE ACTION

Once a thorough evaluation of your home has been made and the sources have been properly identified, a plan of action needs to be developed. It is important to properly identify the sources so that money is not spent needlessly fixing something that is not the major problem. The basic strategies of any action plan are:
1. Eliminate the sources whenever possible
2. Separate the source from the rest of the house if you can't eliminate it. This is done by sealing in the source or air sealing the house to prevent the entry of outdoor contaminants or by creating one safe, clean oasis within the house.
3. Ventilate to evacuate pollutants and bring in fresh clean air (filters may be needed depending on the quality of outside air). Ventilation does not replace the elimination of the offending sources but it is necessary to provide clean air at an affordable cost. This applies to both newer tightly sealed houses and to older homes.

The action plan can be phased in over a period of time (start with the least costly and most effective solutions first) or done all at once depending on the needs of the individuals and the resources available. It may involve minor renovations or modifications, major alterations or even relocation to another home or the construction of a new custom home.

In conclusion, there are many factors in our environment that are difficult to control, but the elimination of pollutants in our home is not one of them. This is something we have control over and can choose to do something about, assuming we have the knowledge to make informed choices. CMHC reminds us that regardless of our health needs, clean indoor air can provide the basis for a nurturing environment. It can improve the quality of our health and our sense of well being. It is therefore deserving of our attention and our resources

REFERENCES:
1. Breecher, Maury M., and Shirley Linde. Healthy Homes in a Toxic World. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1992.
2. "The Clean Air Guide, CMHC, " CMHC NHA 6695 (1993)
3. CMHC, "Healthy Housing: A Guide to a Sustainable Future," CMHC NHA 6725 (1993)
4. EPA and CPSC, "The Inside Story: A Guide to Indoor Air Quality," EPA 402-k-93-0007 (September 1993)
5. "Housing for the Environmentally Hypersensitive," prepared for CMHC Research Division, CMHC PE 0090 (July 1990)
6. Leclair, Kim and Rousseau, David. Environmental by Design. Washington (USA) and British Columbia (Canada): Hartley and Marks, 1992
7. Pearson, David. The Natural House Book. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1989

OTHER RESOURCES:

EPA and CMHC have a number of other publications available. Local offices can provide information.øRousseau,David, Rea W.J. and Enwright Jean. Your Home, Your Health and Well-Being. Berkeley:Ten Speed Press, 1988

Bower, John. Healthy House. New York: Carol Communications, 1989.

Ashford, N., and Miller, C. Chemical Exposures: Low levels and High Stakes. New York: Van Nostrand and Reinhold, 1991

Dadd, Debra Lynn. Non-Toxic, Natural and Earthwise. Los Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher Inc., 1990

Venolia, Carol. Healing Environments. Berkeley: Celestial Arts, 1988

NEWSLETTERS
1) Environmental Building News, RR 1 Box 161, Brattleboro, Vt 05301
2) Environmental Resource Guide, American Institute of Architects, 9 Jay Gould Court, PO Box 753, Waldorf, MD 20604
3) The Environmental Review, Citizens for a Better Environment, 647 W Virginia Street, #305, Milwaukee, WI 53204

DIRECTORIES:
1) Home Grown Green,Richard Kimbell,105 Franklin, Roseville, CA 95678
2) Chemical Injury Information Network, Cynthia Wilson, tel:406 547-2255
3) National Green Pages, Co-op America, 1612 K Street NW, suite 600, Washington, DC 200006
4) Tackling Toxics in Everyday Products: A directory of organizations, by Nancy Lilienthal, Michele Ascione, Adam Flint, Inform Inc., 381 Park Ave So., New York, NY 10016-8806
5) Environmental Health and Toxicology: A selected bibliography of printed information sources, US Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control, National Center for Environmental Health, Information Resources Management Group Atlanta, Georgia 30333

Reprinted from The Endometriosis Sourcebook by permission from the publishers Contemporary Books, Inc. Chicago, Illinois Authors Mary Lou Ballweg and the Endometriosis Association Copyright 1995 by the Endometriosis Association ISBN: 0-8092-3263-4

By Lyse M. Tremblay, Architect




Shop by Keywords Above or by Categories Below.


* * * COMPANIES & PRODUCTS * * *
AIR PURIFICATION AROMATHERAPY BABIES
BEDDING BIRDING BODY CARE
BOOKS BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES BUSINESS-TO-BUSINESS
CAMPING CATALOGUES CLASSIFIEDS
CLEANING PRODUCTS CLOTHING COMPUTER PRODUCTS
CONSTRUCTION CONSULTANTS CRAFTS
ECO KIDS ECO TRAVEL EDUCATION
ENERGY CONSERVATION ENERGY EFFICIENT HOMES ENGINEERING
FITNESS FLOWERS FOODS
FOOTWEAR FURNITURE GARDEN
GIFTS HARDWARE HEMP
HERBS HOUSEHOLD INDUSTRY
INVESTMENTS JEWELRY LIGHTING
MAGAZINES MUSIC NATURAL HEALTH
NATURAL PEST CONTROL NEW AGE OFFICE
OUTDOORS PAPER PETS
PROMOTIONAL RESOURCES RECYCLED SAFE ENVIRONMENTS
SEEKING CAPITAL SHELTERS SOLAR-WIND
TOYS TRANSPORTATION VIDEOS
VITAMINS WATER WEATHER
WHOLESALE WOOD HOW TO ADVERTISE

 Green Shopping Magazine
Updated Daily!

* * * IN-HOUSE RESOURCES * * *
WHAT'S NEW ACTIVISM ALERTS DAILY ECO NEWS
LOCAL RESOURCES DATABASE ASK THE EXPERTS ECO CHAT
ECO FORUMS ARTICLES ECO QUOTES
INTERVIEWS & SPEECHES NON-PROFIT GROUPS ECO LINKS
KIDS LINKS RENEWABLE ENERGY GOVERNMENT/EDUCATION
VEGGIE RESTAURANTS ECO AUDIO/VIDEO EVENTS
COMMUNICATIONS WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING ACCOLADES
AWARDS E-MAIL MAILING LIST

EcoMall